This comparison is for lawyers who are already sold on AI contract redlining and are deciding between two Word-native tools that come up constantly in the same shortlist: Gavel Exec and Spellbook.
Both live inside Microsoft Word. Both aim to speed up drafting and review.
But they are built for different styles of legal work.
| Before writing this rundown for you, I asked Gavel for a Gavel Exec coupon code. Save this code somewhere to save 5%: AI4LAWFIRMS-EXEC5 |
Quick verdict (before the deep dive)
Choose Gavel Exec if you care most about:
- Playbook-driven redlining that reflects how your firm negotiates
- Consistency across contracts and lawyers
- Using precedent and rules, not just AI suggestions
- Treating AI as a structured first-pass reviewer
Choose Spellbook if you care most about:
- Fast drafting and clause suggestions
- Ad-hoc rewriting and brainstorming
- A lighter, more generative AI experience
- Solo or small-team transactional work
Neither tool is “better” in the abstract. They solve slightly different problems.
Core difference in philosophy
Gavel Exec
Gavel Exec is positioned around playbooks, rules, and consistency.
Its goal is to help lawyers redline contracts the same way, every time, based on internal standards and prior deals.
Think:
- enforce preferred positions
- flag deviations
- apply fallback language
- reduce variance across reviewers
Spellbook
Spellbook is positioned around AI-assisted drafting and review.
Its strength is generating language, suggesting edits, and helping lawyers move faster when writing or revising clauses.
Think:
- rewrite this clause
- suggest an alternative
- improve clarity
- generate drafts quickly
That philosophical difference shows up everywhere else.
Redlining approach: rules vs suggestions
Gavel Exec
- Emphasizes rule-based redlining
- Designed to apply internal playbooks
- Best for identifying what does not meet your standards
- Redlines feel closer to how a senior lawyer would mark up a document
This is especially valuable when:
- multiple lawyers review similar contracts
- consistency matters more than creativity
- junior reviewers need guardrails
Spellbook
- Emphasizes suggestion-based redlining
- Uses LLMs to propose changes
- Great for improving language quickly
- Less opinionated about what is “acceptable” vs “unacceptable”
This works well when:
- you want ideas, not enforcement
- contracts vary widely
- you’re drafting more than negotiating
Playbooks and precedent
This is the biggest practical difference.
Gavel Exec
- Marketed around learning from prior documents and guidelines
- Better suited for firms that already have:
- preferred clause language
- negotiation positions
- internal standards
Spellbook
- Has clause libraries and benchmarks
- Less focused on enforcing your specific playbook
- More focused on helping you write better language faster
If your firm already says,
“We never accept X, we usually counter with Y, and Z requires escalation,”
Gavel Exec aligns more naturally with that mindset.
Drafting vs negotiation support
| Use case | Gavel Exec | Spellbook |
|---|---|---|
| First-pass contract review | Strong | Strong |
| Enforcing firm standards | Stronger | Lighter |
| Clause drafting from scratch | Moderate | Stronger |
| Negotiation consistency | Stronger | Moderate |
| Solo drafting speed | Moderate | Strong |
Learning curve and adoption
Gavel Exec
- Slightly more structured
- Best when someone defines rules/playbooks upfront
- Pays off over repeated use
Spellbook
- Very quick to start
- Minimal setup
- Immediate value for individual lawyers
This difference often mirrors firm maturity:
- newer or solo practices lean Spellbook
- established teams lean Gavel Exec
Pricing and trial experience (high level)
Both tools:
- Offer Word-based integrations
- Use subscription pricing
- Provide free trials
Spellbook advertises a short trial focused on drafting and review.
Gavel Exec’s trial is often used to test redlining and workflow fit.
Exact pricing varies by plan and usage, so the trial experience matters more than list prices.
Which one fits your workflow?
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do we want AI to suggest ideas or enforce standards?
- Do multiple lawyers need to redline contracts consistently?
- Are we optimizing for drafting speed or negotiation discipline?
- Do we already have preferred language we want followed?
If your answers skew toward consistency, rules, and repeatability, Gavel Exec is usually the better fit.
If they skew toward speed, drafting, and flexibility, Spellbook may feel more natural.
Both Gavel Exec and Spellbook are credible Word-native AI tools.
The decision is less about features and more about how you practice law.
- Spellbook shines as a drafting copilot.
- Gavel Exec shines as a redlining and negotiation assistant.
If your goal is AI contract redlining that mirrors how your firm actually negotiates, Gavel Exec is the more aligned choice.
Before you sign up, use our special code to save 5% on Gavel Exec:
Affiliate disclosure
Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.